Hi Y__,
Remember me? Nick’s mate. I’m living in Sweden now and planning
to go to Cannes next month. Just wondering if you’re going this year so
we can hook up.
If not, do you have any tips for me? Did you buy accreditation? Is it
worth going without?? Know anywhere cheap to stay??? Still haven’t
organized accommodation yet.
Anyway, let me know how you are getting on.
Cheers,
C
I received the above e-mail from a friend’s friend, and it has finally prompted me to do what I’ve been postponing for 2 years – Blog about my crazy experiences when myself and my filmmaking partner, P, decided to take our film script to Cannes to seek financing, and hit the Big Time!
So thanks C___! I will forgive you the pint of beer you owed me at the Quarryman’s last time we met before you flew off to Sweden. Or maybe you can buy me that beer some point down the track if you find any of the following helpful. Make it two beers and a dinner. I’m still smarting over being dudded a pint.
As with all practical guides, the advice I proffer to you, my humble acolyte, makes no sense unless one understands the context in which the advice is formed.
Two full years have passed since I did these deeds, and circumstances may well have changed in Cannes, and the World is definitely a different place for obvious reasons. Also, myself and P are two very different people to you, with our own strengths and weaknesses. We knew what they were, and covered our weaknesses, and exploited our strengths. Like us, C, you will have to identify your own strengths and weaknesses and devise your own strategies to make the most of your own circumstances.
But, C, I can sense your impatience. Without further ado…
I’ll start at the beginning.
P had approached me in late January 2007, to help him write a feature film script. Although both being Chinese, we didn’t know each other. Yes, even we Chinese assume we’ll know each other, and half-expect we’ll be somehow related. But no. We were not related. And what little we’d seen of each other was in the amateur film context. P was an aspiring actor, with from what I knew of him, one small low-budget Australian independent feature film to his name, and a few bit parts in commercials, usually as the token Asian.
P had auditioned for my own short film which I never ended up making. I hope to write about this experience at a later point in time. P was conspicuous to me through his terrible audition, well-intentioned though it may have been.
During the audition, as P did his best dead-pan “nerd” impression, wearing his father’s glasses, increasing his difficulties and distractions, my production assistant could not stifle a giggle. I shot an angry look at her and she quickly brought her hand to her mouth, but to no avail.
Summoning all my own reserves not to laugh myself, I choked down the belly laugh coming up my oesophagus. To my left, my utterly professional dramaturg, CY, was also quivering in contrast to her decidedly serious expression. She was clearly struggling too.
So it was that this day P called me and asked to meet me to discuss an idea he wanted to pitch to me.
We met at the QVB for a coffee, his girlfriend J also in attendance, presumably to offer him moral support.
“So what’s the ‘hot idea’?”, I asked.
P looked serious for a moment. Oh dear. Was he going to try his “serious nerd”-look again? I wasn’t going to be able to keep it down this time.
“Have you heard about the “Pick-Up” phenomenon?”
Y: “Yes. I read an article about it in the Good Weekend a couple of years ago.”
P: Oh? What did you think?
Y: I’ve done it myself, and I was checking to see if he used similar methods. I think our methods overlap.
P was aghast.
P: So you know what it’s based on?
Y: I was using Pavlovian conditioning, and a whole bunch of other stuff.
P: I’ve tried these techniques myself.
P’s girlfriend shifted uncomfortably in her seat.
P (noticing): But of course I never follow through with it. It’s based on being the alpha male.
Y: It sounds a little different to my approach, but there still sounds like a lot of overlap already.
P: So you know what my idea is?
Y: Yes. You want to make a film about this pick-up artist stuff and you want to star in it, and you want me to produce it. Right?
P: (Gaping). J: (Also gaping)
P (spluttering); H-h-h-ow did you know?
Y: I’d already had the idea myself.
P and J were aghast again. Upon recovering himself:-
P: So do you want to produce it?
P had last seen me studying producing at film school. But something I’d learned in producing school was that I did not want to produce anything I was not completely passionate about. I told P this.
P: So you don’t want to produce it?
Y: Not if you write it. If I had a hand in the writing process I might be more committed to it.
P (stumbling over himself): S-s-so would you like to co-write it with me?
Y: Here’s the deal: You star, we co-write, and we co-produce. I direct.
P: That sounds great!
J smiled in appreciation and support.
P and I met over the next few weeks to discuss the film. Being the senior filmmaker in this relationship, I acted more as a mentor, asking questions of P, and guiding him. What was key to me was to see if P had enough “fire” in his belly and enough motivation.
What most people don’t realize is that “talent” is secondary to motivation, even in a business like film. It’s like Sun Tzu said – “Heart is the most important fighting quality above all others.”
If P and I were to embark on a film project together, I had to see if P had enough fire to last the distance.
In our first meeting I asked P to tell me about the film he had envisaged.
P distinguished himself by presenting a very sound 5 minute précis of his film idea, with a beginning, middle and end (3 act structure.)
P, at the very least, had an excellent memory, a quality that would help our exploits balancing out my poor memory.
But P struggled with the next step.
Y: What is your film really about?
P: About picking up.
Y: I mean, what is it about in a thematic sense. You quote Star Wars a lot. Those films were all about the hero’s journey. All hero journeys are about self-discovery. In the Empire Strikes Back, the hero’s journey is very clearly written out, with Luke Skywalker facing numerous challenges – but ultimately his biggest challenge is to confront himself. What do you think your pick-up film is about?
P: Umm, it’s about self-discovery?
OK. P was a good parrot, but did he really get the thematic subtleties that were needed under the surface of a well-written and tightly plotted, well-characterised film script?
I had to make it easier for him.
Y: What is your film really about? What is the central message that you wish to convey with your film? See, for example, Silence of the Lambs, although a psychological horror film has a central message beyond just wanting to scare the pants off us. The writer was really saying that in life, we need to change, but change is painful. See how, despite all the fireworks of Jodie Foster and Anthony Hopkins performances, and great dialogue, that the central message lies under the surface of every scene?
P gave more attempts, but he really didn’t get it. As with everything with Paul, his themes and needs were staring me right in the face. Story after story of how he’d faced disappointment in the dating scene. It was so obvious what he wanted and how it would fit into the hero’s journey. Only he couldn’t see it.
Y: OK. I want you to think about this issue of “theme” and come back to me with what you think it is. In the meantime, I want you to also try to write down the first draft of what you just said to me. It already sounds like a 3 act structure.
Just before we parted, P turned on his worn-through sneaker heels.
P: We’ve been talking a lot about strengths and weaknesses and knowing ourselves. What do you think is your greatest weakness?
I thought for a moment. It was clear enough to me what my weakness had been in these past few years. After running a film competition only to find others were less competent in filmmaking than myself, after producing yet more films at film school to the same effect, I knew what my weakness was. But should I tell him? I shrugged and told him.
Y: My greatest weakness is the flipside of my strength. I’m very good at understanding what other people like and want, but sometimes I ignore what it is that I truly want.
P did one of his characteristic, exaggerated nods of acknowledgement, before turning quickly and bounding up the stairs for his train.
A week later P and I met again, in the same location. P had dutifully completed a first draft of his script. I asked him again what he thought the theme of his film was. Again, he stumbled, and grasped at straws, throwing back at me whatever words he could remember I’d said. ”Uncanny memory this boy”, I thought to myself. But it didn’t disguise the fact that he was no closer to his thematic core than last week.
I read through his script quickly.
I was puzzled. It was as if he had read from a book called “How to write your screenplay in three easy steps”, and did exactly what the book told him, word for word.
And the results spoke for itself. It was as if he’d grabbed the scriptwriting cookie-cutter off the shelf and stamped it onto the dough. Voila. A script.
All the characters were two dimensional. The scenes were formulaic, and everything was telegraphed and predictable.
P was like that student in primary school who always finishes first, but has done the task so hurriedly in their effort to finish first, they have missed the point of the exercise, be it art, or creative writing, or even a maths problem. P was all about “end result” and nothing about process.
Nevertheless, the themes I had surmised P was wanting to write about in his screenplay were all too apparent.
Asian guy wants to pick up Caucasian chicks, but can’t because he’s Asian. Already two themes cried out from this premise.
1) Asian guy can’t pick up because society’s negative stereotypes emasculate Asian men.
2) What is it to be a man? Is it all about picking-up, or is it about something deeper? Isn’t it more about being responsible. Nevertheless, it is still an essential part of man to be sexual.
In that second meeting, I even taunted P by writing down the answer I thought it was, on a piece of paper, and placed it face down before him.
I spent the next 20 minutes again probing P for the answer to the question that so obviously sprawled across the pages of his first draft. It was an exasperating game of “Hot” and “Cold”, with P just doing his party trick of repeating exactly what he said when I said “Hot”, without ever getting any more insight into his answer. He was stuck, and because he insisted upon parroting, instead of understanding the game continued, with much hand-waving and gesturing and hinting from me until finally…
P: Um, it’s about how, umm, white girls just don’t respect us Asian dudes man?!
Y: Yes!!!
It had been stated more as a question than an answer by P, but he had finally touched upon one of the basic themes that would underpin the script, and be its beating heart.
To be continued.